© 2007 Institute of Current World Affairs
The Institute awards long-term fellowships to develop a deep understanding of an issue, country, or region outside the US and to share that understanding with a wider public.
Institute of Current World Affairs - Home Page

Below is a hobbled text version of a PDF document.
In order to read the actual document please click the link below and register if necessary.
(One-time registration is free and very quick.)
Read article

6/1/1992 - Beating around the Bushmen a controversy revisited by Casey C. Kelso

CCK INSTITUTEOFCURRENTWORLDAFFAIRS Beatinq around Bushmen controversy revisited Casey Kelso Wakefield Lodge Wakefield Road Avondale Harare Zimbabwe June Peter Bird Martin Institute Current World Affairs West Wheelock Street Hanover New Hampshire 03755 Dear Peter In bookshop which I ventured there nervous actors waiting audition hoping break could launch movie career At glance I could South African director criteria casting leading tentatively titled A Far Off Place The young African varying degrees professional polish short possessed Bushman characteristics cheekbones rounded Each advertisement daily newspaper ACTOR WANTED OPEN AUDITION Lead international feature An international company planning classic African story Zimbabwe Namibia W looking small coloured actor Bushman starring Do following requirements No taller Bushman San features Speak English years Physically The Xhabbo require considerable research rehearsal actor Irmela Erlank assisting casting director search Third World He speak English discipline terribly difficult finding Bushman They naive actors since mature intelligent around civilization It nothing movie The Gods Mst Be Craz Casey Kelso Institute fellow studying Southern African societies economies production systems Since Institute Current World Affairs Crane Rogers Foundation provided fellowships enable outstanding young adults outside United States write international areas issues Endowed bythelateCharlesR Crane theInstituteisalsosupportedbycontributionsfromlike mindedindividualsand foundations The revolves around hearted culturally assimilated Bushman named Xhabbo meets Namibian Bushman children Zimbabwe somehow return their family The story their adventures journey makings office smash including small inoffensive Third World people smaller loveable children untouched African vastness exists Western imagination absurdly simple politics That formula created instant popularity The Gods Must Be Crazy sequel which earned South African movie producer James Uys millions foreign exchange during country financial drought created apartheid boycott In first blockbuster comedy ingenuous Bushman return Coke bottle modern becomes embroiled antics white wildlife biologist slapstick communist insurgency masterminded white Trotsky alike lurking The requirement movie speak English eliminated consideration Bushman includin Gao Oma starred The Gods Must Be Crazy That ironic situation South Africans hirin Bushman commercially lucrative movie about Bushmen highlights world would prefer exploit romanticism about their hunter gatherer society while ignoring their impoverished reality And additional twist movie filmed outside Botswana although logically takes place inside country The couldn possibly Botswana The government condemns earlier movies portraying Bushman idyllic which fosters international outrage about official efforts integrate Bushmen larger Tswana society Politicians Bushmen development means largely destroying their culture further special attention ethnic group unwelcome Since I wrote February newsletter misery cultural disintegration Bushmen Botswana controversy heated rolling Foreign journalists expatriate development workers missionaries white Botswana citizens vehemently disparaged state politicians ostensibly causing dissent dissatisfaction among Bushmen Apparently Botswana government holds subtly conveyed South African screenwriter The Gods Rural Africans couldn militant without outside white leader pulling strings behind scenes And while these broadsides authorities printed daily Botswana state controlled newspaper white guests active Bushman affairs quietly being forced leave country This counter attack launched weeks following publication damnin report alleing torture Bushmen hands police wildlife officials other human rights violations The frankly worded paper written daughter cabinet minister young British trained lawyer unintimidated storm outrage account would provoke The Bushmen quoted throughout report under government officials punish those complaining outsiders In serious Bushman people living around Botswana remote northern Ghanzi where human rights survey conducted South African Pastor Braam La Roux being forced leave Botswana The government simply refused renew permit If remember newsletter Botswana I searching successful development projects involving Bushmen region around Ghanzi I La Roux Kuru Development Trust D Kar La Roux worked since hectare foster development projects initiated Bushman people themselves The worked encourage industries leather tanning sewing groups setting primary school adult education classes As coordinator member community La Roux facilitated means hunter gather society adaption complex modern world operates basis money literacy ownership business acumen Perhaps La Roux greatest achievement trust organizational structure which designed promote controlled development mixing Bushman traditional consensus making western style democratic executive committee Each Bushman enterprise D Kar sends delegate council meets technical staff discuss projects Important decisions submitted public meeting procedure allow collective decisions egalitarian Bushman manner talking subject death before action Discussions everyone their English Afrikaans Nharo click language The Kuru Development Trust successful government officials taken prospective foreign donors visit bypassing wretched state relocation settlements where residents poverty matches their apathy Such conspicuous accomplishment enemie among local district officials embarrassed inevitable comparison D Kar their programs Even things going D Kar La Roux success Bushman development fragile During conversation earlier La Roux believed positive confrontational approach dealng government The Bushman issue emotional rational right because ethnicity There extreme ensitivity ethnicity legacy South Africa Botswana We trying slowly program could flagship Bushman policy Both La Roux Wilhelmina speak local Nharo dialect Both planned proving their proficiency during examination obtain Botswana citizenship That appears destroyed longer welcome Botswana Ironically Wilhelmina raised Ghanzi citizenship marrying foreigner There numerous indications denial bureaucratic oversight For example I found brief reference Kuru Development Trust newsletter published Kalahari Support Group based The Netherlands The support group could raised funds representatives Bushmen D Kar attend summer United Nation Year Indigenous Peoples conference But La Roux declined offer stating early international gatherings Not because Kuru would spokesperson because board members because still vulnerable towards suspicion negative reactions people around government A clear warning during public meeting D Kar Ghanzi District Commissioner Samuel Rathedi The Kuru Development Trust councilmembers feeling assertive their exercise genuine democracy wanted elect their representative headman Bushman community Without consulting D Kar residents local authorities simply appointed their administer settlement affairs The Bushmen protested Rathedi about imposition Tswana outsider their formal spokesman Rathedi responded warning avoid tribalistic tendencies dangerous The people backed after Rathedi veiled threat against La Roux suspects fomenting trouble Sa Rathedi Church leaders unite community separate The controversial report alleging torture against Bushmen contributed government animosity behind La Roux expulsion Botswana The temperature country political climate authorities tempers several degrees following publication human rights survey funded Botswana Christian Council BCC consortium about dozen church groups country united together speak different issues coordinate charity activities While group receives outside funding Scandinavian countries BCC Botswana citizens And report local person lending credibility conclusions Because controversial nature issue decided Motswana assessment human rights situation assessment which could serve basis further study action BCC General Secretary Churchill Gape G himself Motswana singular Tswana language Botswana citizen As churches remain silent listen cries God people Gape Publishing report Batswana listen cries fellow citizens start changing attitudes making oppressive actions revealed report something The shocking allegations concerned torture severe beatings inflicted Bushmen suspected poaching wildlife The concept poaching difficult Bushmen understand since centuries lived water sources wildlife vegetation Today almost Bushmen moved settlements resembling Tswana villages while their traditional around Ghanzi private hands state wildlife preserve Plowing planting sorghum difficult unfamiliar Bushmen seemingly nonsensical desert scarce erratic rainfall The animals their cattle Bushmen Most cannot understand killing animal survival theft state The author report Alice Mogwe documented widespread instances torture officers Department Wildlife Nature Preservation local police In common torture rubber placed tightly testicles victim while plastic wrapped You castrated Bushman Mogwe You throttled excrete which eaten After lengthy custody sometimes weeks incarceration court usually sentences Bushman individual could according report The Bushmen poach because poverty hunger which considered extenuating circumstance judges In conversations Mogwe government officials stressed enforced stringently regardless desperate circumstances offender Poaching poaching Other equally explosive accusations injustice report concerning alienation forced relocation discrimination housing education employment health The sensitive issue discussed human rights report since involves basic building blocks human behavior greed interest power others The Bushmen argue historically preceded settlement black white people district Unfortunately government formed anthropologists conclusions Bushmen traditional territories roamed Such generalizations distinction between seven different roups Bushmen familiar their defined environment starvation disorientation moved In Botswana Attorney General issued opinion Masarwa Bushmen always nomads owing allegiance chief tribe nomad rights except rights hunting In addition white farms settled century large tracts lands allocated relatively affluent Tswana commercial production further rupturing Bushman close relationship evictions The government created settled communities squatters forcibly relocated Today Bushmen local authorities cajole compel moving settlements Mogwe found I terms Bushmen government discussions illustrate passive critical decisions concerning their lives As I noted previous essay Bushman preferred almost though originally carried pejorative sense Officially however hunter gatherers known Basarwa Tswana derives negative description Ba dlkomo those raise cattle In cattle crazy Tswana culture disapproving connotation The Remote Area Dweller Tswana language equivalent Ba tengnyanaten which means those inside upset Bushmen Mogwe They asked It thing which inside earth Has their covered Does Even Batswana which plural Tswana Botswana citizens sparked resentment The Bushmen describe other ethnic groups black people while themselves people The authorities refusal accept their words definition confirms Bushmen being merged society anonymous collective Batswana The Motswana wants culture Basarwa disappear Bushman The controversy La Roux revolves around extreme sensitivity tribe Both government officers Bushman activists apartheid talking about situation We apartheid Botswana homelands special privileges Bushmen government spokesman Proponents Bushman rights condemn government apartheid discrimination seizure I understand government wariness allowing ethnic group clamor separate status I fratricidal tribal conflicts other parts Africa Yet I think Bushman controversy touches deeper issue African assertiveness against control Western countries When delegation Bushmen recently journeyed capital Gaborone government officials given stern lecture Pelonomi Venson permanent secretary Ministry Local Government Lands Housing She warned about indigenous minorities fashion under whose guise outsiders Basarwa tourist attraction Venson government Botswana signatory international conventions state develop integrate Basarwa improving their standards living Mogwe findings torture human rights violations dismissed government distortions promoted white neocolonialist foreigners And expatriates criticizing Botswana domestic policies A Botswana Christian Council worker white clearly found beyond which When I asked about government response report balked As white I about That would carrying The white foreigner seems pronounced Gaborone compared months The hostility large casual conversation between expatriates Botswana these An American professor university being jostled aside office important Botswana businessman When white female academic black queue cried Why where Usually professor remarked other Batswana would supported standing against bully This however everyone remained silent tense The expatriate development worker related recent confrontation Botswana driver doubled parked behind blocking After inconsiderate ewner finally returned American woman yelled This United States retorted We Batswana country The white woman voicing frustrations building And starve These tales westerner could after short sojourn foreign But significant Alec Campbell British became naturalized Botswana citizen decades As author numerous books about Botswana official Guide Book Campbell authority aspects adopted country culture history environment Campbell founded national museum remains driving force behind Botswana Society influential group industrialists businessmen politicians counts government ministers members Yet after completing government sponsored study Bushmen Serowe major Botswana Serowe District Council rebuffed Campbell presented findings We outsiders would tellin Basarwa council reportedly Campbell Why This dedicated preserving promoting Botswana heritage environment In another calculated insult council decided conduct entire meeting Tswana language which Campbell lacks fluency Previously Serowe District Council always conducted meetings English official language Botswana government reports parliamentary bills In controversies environmentally damaging policies dredging pristine wildlife areas erecting barbed fences across wildlife migration routes government lambasted white Europeans meddling their affairs Yet Botswana respond threats publicity Diamonds Death campaign Greenpeace compromises policy reversals The found international concern about rights indigenous peoples lever Bushmen their struggle against pervasive discrimination But leverage temporary phenomenon because international attention fickle Just Gao Oma propelled stardom The Gods Must Be Crazy Among Bushmen living around northern Namibian Tsumkwe known money But memento Gao former celebrity status T shirt bearing image fellow Bushman actor dressed suits Gao received Rand monthly months films money Strangely enough Gao South African lawyer charge financial affairs doesn Gao enjoyed making movies because slept Now waits another white person roofed shack another offer He asked Do actors other countries straw houses Are without A shake prompted Gao In those people I acting little cleverer I stupid For Bushmen I world latest concern about indigenous peoples passing The United Nations Decade Women ended example prompt awareness importance women development Yet after hullabaloo effort lasting changes resulted Just recently I watched development gather Southern Africa seminars marking Year Child River Blindness Action Month Disabled Awareness Day Each issue quickly fades public after conventioneers leave Like promoting status women preserving endangered species changing prevailing prejudice against Bushmen Botswana years And international money attention could vanishing culture Sincerely Received Hanover July