© 2007 Institute of Current World Affairs
The Institute awards long-term fellowships to develop a deep understanding of an issue, country, or region outside the US and to share that understanding with a wider public.
Institute of Current World Affairs - Home Page

Below is a hobbled text version of a PDF document.
In order to read the actual document please click the link below and register if necessary.
(One-time registration is free and very quick.)
Read article

2/24/1975 - Justice, Et Al by Richard J. Balzer

NOT FOR PUBLICATION WITHOUT WRITER S CONSENT ISTITUTE OF CURRENT WORLD AFFAIRS harle8 River Road Watertown Nasa 021T2 lbruary Mr ehard H Nolte Ltute G urrnt World 5FhAvene New York Ne York 10017 Ds Mr Nolte astLee sorts served September eourtrooa peeli green walls Salea Superior whieh watched larger portrat little known deceased lawyer Judge scene eompromlse residents Sauus Mobile Park landlords The settlement ended dspute stretched ourten agonsing months It arked rumor threats Neighbors trned aganst other strong tnantst assoelaton deteriorated badly twenty Parkas resdents Superior Court settle Assreaders mayre emberromRB ardms Fall Saunabllerk only1 tlaldstred increase toren tents rgand taidoalaltselecanatdedtneaseor onths InJamua landldssenttawnotre thistmdng Ths demand gnored almost Park resdents On March anuarF cheeks returned letter thratenng eveton landlords demand An emergencyetng whichmypeople expressed events After tenson illed eetLn deeded With adwLee lawyer gehoe again March Marches cheeks returned early thratengletterntheoroan eetonnotee Theletterstated thatevictionproeeedngs wouldb eoeeneneed ifwedd theentLre amount lnmedately Rehard Baler Insttute ellow explortrt Elects soeLal economic ehane middl elass Aerca As reported communication upset peopIe possibly homes began spread AlthouKh there brave about ckading Route One mobile homes evicted people seared Sons au1es capitulated landlords demands One feisty sixty seven Increase hated buths seventyFear oldsister wthwhoahe taking doctor prescribed sedatives eouldntt stand tensone I eonaluded R3B stating although Association strength eroded decided fight increase If meant golng court Our attorney durng first explain legal position should court Although presented osltion layer languag could three people still uneertaln legal position So within Stev am1ies single spaced typed statement outlining legal position The statement began these reassuring words eviction proess attempt negotialons There tndeaton present happen Stee elain legal position which boiled eontenton notice landlords demanding increases legally sutcent Ths based theory tenancy month lease landlord terminate exstLng tenaney tenaney Tim statement concluded following statement For arthernoraattonandaceomindt clearthatthenersdonot tottoectyorttg stated youroers andbothhsat Natt nager gopan statedthfstome Soyoushldnotqovvy autenasstbleeetonatmptatthst ovewang andtto ppare Nay First month later without warning parktsffty ghtfam1eshowrest11 paying servedby sheriff writs declarations summary process notices court proceedings eeneed evicted Near panic An ergeneF meeting calle meeting famLltes additional At meeting people asking Steve reassuranoe strong legal Steve warned thate might local level heard Jdge sympathetic landlordst probably IX would appeal Superior Court Jury better chance winning To people sense eonused others Many people wondered could postLon right Others seemed understand although Steve right ImpIled decisions District Court areaffeeted forces other legal arguments Feeula seemed positon He these m11Lons They grease palms ehanee You never Onthesxteentho ldayapproxJjnatelyftyresidentsothepark toLynnDistrictCourt Itwasrfirstopportttowitness landlords attoey action presenting eltents eaSeNtnt tiradeabt landlord right anrease aboutrtcabeingadry andaboutnogrouo tenetshavingtrighttodtatehalandlord hisbuSess inished saying these tenants other tenan choice Fan increase Steve presented elaimng notice increase legally sueient neffeettve Ths Judge ruled favor landlords Many resdents defeat though Steve warned there chance It Steve present fully Why allowed Steve about harrassmsnt ntimdaton Several people began questiqn eompeter lawyer unfavorable comparisons between performance court landlords lawyer impressed shomnan lawyer His knowledge overwhelmng assertve almost beilLe personal deportment Lu courtroom Iwassurprisedtolearnhomanyotheparks residents hadbeen impressed NLff Thsy eomnented expensive foreefulnesl Steve manyo these people sufered Ln oompar80n Steve Ls radical lawyer specializing representat0ne charging remarkably I learned people voltLeal deeLsLon being young inexperienced Iawyer Steve dressert shoes suits baggy people belisved dressed reflect about eIothes butthat hscouldn taordmoreexpensiveeIothng Stove courtroom style dfferent Nff reled court deetsons assevtve stTle eople demeanor reflecting tnsecurtF lawyer Joe Thomas sunned doubts people havtg Don wrong Steve takes courtroom Confidence ssoeaton lawyer declned Nevertheless there tenants determd through Mary Stack sayng taking State Suprema Court In ssocaton deeded appeal DstrLct Court decston nsttute claimng harrassment damages The Sueror Court locatedn closed suemer nally August 8oston Sueror speedytral sdecisionwrpted trealisatontttlr tcasedraedon tmeolewereabandoningtsoeaton Each nthafewmollspaidtrease landlordsstha sensedthseausetyaridagatt ourmotor dFtria Jdted motion andpraised anearlyS tmrcourt At stack faced challenge A growing dissident faction upset Hary leadershp around someone electon struggle against Mary I approached about running presidency I wouldn I msgvtngs about style I tooktehresponsibility onrseiandddn tsharenoton ocers I cmtted andertoths struggletnyOelsehadenwllngto content prestdent lttng statement suorttn Wat uting8 I I might preetdent again psfdent E1en other ideas She disturbed amount I stepfng aetons smoothng ru1ed feathers holding hands She ntervupted dinners tghtro walking personality squabbles She exersed polar stepped runnng Fred Hatch Assocation other presdent fnally deede challenge Mary esideney soundly feaeed losing onemargn ssuort erodedtsstillenfold esupporttyoelse estggle leadershp rtrweentAssociation Another meetn elled Steve earned unfortunately heard before explained forwardth ourown losttmight seriouslydamage appeal The explanation everyone Steve optons procedure followed throughout eourt proceedings We could press Although hinted preferred dropping concentrating appeal landlords never Stev preferred deLson This cedure X intellectually appreciate however clear group options decision People Steve Stev wouldn until so0ne nally Steve lawer should Reluctantly thought should Work appeal There plaints people quickly voted Stev suggested There great exetent among forty residents Superior NondaySpteaber finally going heard Jury They would people thought listen toourcase andJustcewoudbeserved wewouldn The proved dsappontment The Judge called opposing attorneys chambers urged settlement rather proeede The entLre taken these negotiations nothingo negottatons until Steve emerged judge chambers morning about compromise landlords offered The landlords offer ollos tenants month disputed months starting month Oceroise woman aedately compromise The vocal reaction compromise strident opposition byeoplewhoclamedehadaitedall thistimetohaveourdaytncourt andtheydidn twntanything stopusno canwin onewoman should compromise This position everyone Other people willing compromse favorable could Ed Turner tamers losers Ie thman cmart going shake hands going Back forth people argued eoorcse eopromse veral rheas people asked Steve should Hs laying otons avoiding answering question thought calculation Oar group anted drectton options Finally pressed point where thought promise offered nothing Ewe could compromise should People seeed agree Steve No wanted accept We talked about kinds finally after heated debate empovered Steve return negotiations three Eollowng postons ewould willing forget starting month I accepted would willing month months future nothing better could arranged would future That things lunch People pretty optimistic tmlevng landlords negotiate unlesstyre afraidoflg Steve dtsappeared chambers again after lunet emerged about landlords turned three offers submitted their counter offer months future turned offer finally trial The Jury selected Judg recessed court Steve thought trial wouldnVt several tenants taken needed testify Tcase dragged three morning lr8were called Judge chamberst negotLattons would continue settlement wouldn reached It seemed being tried tmteen negotiations On afternoon second lords attorney present called three witnesses Jfny DsCotLs owners parko 31uny DeCots portly headed He wearing expensive msumtched shixt sports coato lawyer guided through testuony requested increase urtng cross examination Steve expand scope direct collateral issues Jtnsys eelngs about Association Nary Stack Hr 14Nfobjectedtomostothequestioningandmostofhs objections dLsmay omost residents sustained It became mmedlately clear nmehi Stev hopedtopresentwouldnotbeallodn rlngtlunch breseralofttenants notquiteunderstandng unppy abtallthestad0bJeetonsked atkndojustice isths nyoueetenpsenttfacts tothe dweeallths tosrpeee Shaking Joe Faesola aside Tou DeOotLs sworthmoretnamillionbue Youthwnhelks dnatSte whoseshsntnvegohls hee8sead ayoukiddn looksattkiddlaugh Id tsayathn backto eeptttIthoutStewasdohsst tIhad bndsappontedtnteouro dsntthklyenouon Steanddlngtheeross tnatton AtopointIgotsod upset Ieoded amssedopptunty Ilett eourtro The afternoon sesson shortened negot landlords offer accept future Sme tenants wanted accept eomproalse However durng early afternoon Jnmy DeOots defamed stack wanted chance story People Nary turned offer saying court Thursday fourth trial returned Wafting ROOm The lawyers called judge chambers Steve emerged landlords willing future Some people settle EspeeLally after Jimny DeCots testion about Hary Hoover0 ofthe thrty people court asking Steve should repeated I think Le sayng anything We argued meres Oould pushed lower Steve thought Fnally people pressed Steve should There avoid 8nswertng He compromise though could suggested compromise nvolved compromise agreement landlords promise would least someth landlord8 previously never Would With mixed emotions Steve settle offer With fourteen months argung One woman there Is ought Another pointed saved nearly through fourteen months settlement We eourtroo tLred eonused totally pleased group Justice wrtten settlement stuffed lawyer brefease Received New York March